Indian democracy seems to be facing a peculiar challenge, which has been, (and might continue for a while) to hold India from becoming a true powerful republic:
- The inability of the people to view leaders, champions and Achievers as just that; and stop making them Gods or Demigods.
Leaders and people showing excellence suddenly are elevated to demi-god status and suddenly they become the toast of nation. They seems to be responsible for all positive happenings; they are filled with only appreciable values; they are made case-studies in various areas of professional and personal lives; there seems nothing wrong can be done by them. Luckily building temples are not yet a wide-spread phenomenon!
Indians are passionate about Cricket – and for all the good things that were happening in Indian Cricket for the last few years, they found a champion – Sachin Tendulkar. Later, they found a champion leader who led Indian Cricket to further heights- M S Dhoni. Tendulkar is seen and even called “GOD” for the past few years; and with the frenzy of the Worldcup win, M S Dhoni has become another demi-god (luckily not another god , not yet at least).
Within days, India got another demi-god who led and initiative about corruption – Anna Hazare. He even surprised Indian themselves with the ability to gather public support across India into one of the biggest public movements in independent India – and succeed in the objective.
The similarities in these two scenarios is very concerning to the advancement of India:
Cricket teamnwins are seen as victories of Sachins and Dhonis. They are hailed as ‘The ones’. Social movement success is viewed as the victory of Anna Hazare.
Everyone wanted ‘Bharata Ratna’ for Tendulkar, now the same for Anna Hazare, even if it means Tendulkar may have to wait. (as the nomination for both have to ideally come from Maharashtra Government).
These are just two scenarios quoted here – but in no way isolated cases. We have gods and semi (or demi) gods in Film stars,artists, Sports persons, Politicians (rare these days) and now in Social workers. This is if you even try and ignore the age old phenomenon of Spiritual leaders and ‘Saints’ becoming Gods and God-men (or God-women!).
Such behavior not only is a challenge to India’s journey forward as a powerful democracy, but also totally unfair to many of these great leaders and champions – and even to those spiritual leaders (except some of those who seemingly enjoy such a privilege).
The reasons why it is unfair to those leaders and achievers are:
- It take the focus away from their true capabilities and achievements
- It puts immense pressure of expectations on them to be perfect and successful. Many of them would know, and would have experienced that they will be dropped down to the other extreme of hatred and condemnment whenever their ‘performances’ start show any signs of less-than-perfection!
- Most often than not, motives are suddenly casted on their decisions, words and actions, once the intial euphoria is gone. After all, they “deserve it” as they were hailed when they did well – there goes the public opinion!
The reason why it is a challenge to India’s progress is:
- The power of people and teamwork is ignored and personal achievements are hailed. The majority end up being ignorant or ignoring the real power behind the achievements and think these can be achieved by only “special people”. The belief system gets strengthened further that we need such ‘incarnations’ to solve our problems and challenges. In short, the people starts losing confidence in themselves and expect some body to come out of the blue and take lead.
Anna Hazare, M S Dhoni and Tendulkar (or a Rajnikanth or should be cases of creating more belief in the people that they are ‘just like us’ and so we can do it! It should motivate the young Indians to take lead in their domains.
Let us just hope the success of the Lokpal bill movement by Anna leads our people to have greater belief in power of people and togetherness for a cause, rather than making another ‘god’ from Anna Hazare.
Let us hope India get into habit of being proud of, and making real use of our heroes than ‘worshipping’ them. India a land of countless ‘Gods’ already, don’t need more Gods, but we can do a lot with our real leaders, champions and excellence.